婚姻登记行政诉讼司法审查研究.pdf

硕士专业学位论文


论文题目婚姻登记行政诉讼司法审查研究

研究生姓名赵亚亚
指导教师姓名周永坤
专业名称法律硕士
研究方向法理学
论文提交日期 2010 年 9 月
II
范性文件行政审查制度研究中文摘要
婚姻登记行政诉讼司法审查研究
中文摘要
针对司法实践中出现的大量的婚姻登记瑕疵纠纷,本文提出,作为具体行政行为
的婚姻登记,可以根据婚姻和婚姻登记行为的特殊性,提起行政诉讼。基于婚姻的性
质,在提起行政诉讼的原告主体资格的范围上,应当根据婚姻登记行政行为的具体情
况而有不同。在对婚姻登记行政行为的司法审查中,通过适用婚姻登记最大程度有效
原则、实质审查原则和对行政机关职权主体、登记的行政程序、认定的事实和适用的
法律的审查,针对不同的审查结果,作出相应的裁判。行政诉讼的判决结果与婚姻的
效力密切相关,判决确认无效的,婚姻自始无效;判决撤销婚姻登记的,应区分对外
效力和对内效力,对外则从判决撤销之日起婚姻关系消灭,对内则以照顾无过错方为
原则,无过错一方可以依婚姻关系取得财产的,享有财产的分配权,应当依婚姻关系
负担债务的,不负担债务;判决确认婚姻登记违法的,对婚姻效力没有影响。

关键词: 婚姻婚姻登记行政诉讼司法审查

作者:赵亚亚
指导教师:周永坤



I
Abstract The Study Of The Judicial Review Of The Marriage Registration Administration Proceedings
The Study Of The Judicial Review Of
The Marriage Registration Administration Proceedings
Abstract
Per regarding the substantial disputes of registration of marriage during the execution
of the judicature, this thesis indicates that the registration of marriage , as a very specific
administration, could be appealed to administrative proceedings base on the singularity of
the registration of marriage and marriage itself. Base on the properties of the marriage, the
detailed of the marriage registration administrative proceedings should be differentiated
considering the marital legitimacy of accuser .The marital law and related statute should be
adopted during judicial review of the marriage registration administration, and different
judgments would be given according to different judicial review results. The judgment is
closely connected with the validity of marriage:
If the judgment defines the marriage invalidity, the marital is invalid from the
beginning.
If the judgment defines the marriage repealed: then e to two effectiveness:
the marital relationship termination by the judgment date, and the unerring party would
possess the right of the property distribution with the marital relationship, while no
responsibility for the debt burden if any